Domestic Affairs

The Myth of American Exceptionalism

In a fantasy world, input equates to output. Great effort results in great accomplishments. Consequently, great accomplishments lead to great success. One can rewrite their fate through hard work and ambition. Put differently, through determination, you can achieve upward economic mobility. This is the essence of the American Dream and why so many migrate to the United States despite being explicitly unwelcome. According to the Migration Policy Institute, despite the Trump administration’s goal of 1 million annually, an estimated 660,000 people have been deported in the previous fiscal year. The idea that economic success can influence one’s quality of life is appealing. This belief has given the U.S. a sense of economic hierarchy.

Consider how this is codified in political platforms to dictate school instruction. The Texas Republican Party Platform explicitly states: “[The] instruction [of Social studies, including geography, economics, and US and world history] shall focus on American exceptionalism, the benefits of the free-enterprise system, and the consistent failures of socialism and communism.”

By requiring students to learn about the “benefits” of the free-enterprise system alongside the “consistent failures” of socialism and communism, the Republican platform presents a political interpretation. Rather than treating the success of the American economic system as a question open to examination, their framing begins with a conclusion. The implication here is that American exceptionalism is tied to the free-enterprise system.

The connection between the free-enterprise system and American exceptionalism can be tested empirically. American exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is distinctive and exemplary compared to other nations, often with the implication that it is both destined and entitled to play a distinct role on the world stage. Such a strong belief must be founded in empirical reality. This raises a direct question: what evidence could contradict that claim?

To test economic exceptionalism, the American economic system must be evaluated by its own outcomes. If the free-enterprise system is a defining reason for American exceptionalism, then the United States should demonstrate economic outcomes that are meaningfully superior to those of comparable nations, particularly in areas such as economic growth, stability, and income distribution. Conflicting evidence would weaken the claim that the free-enterprise system contributes to America’s economic exceptionalism.

American history complicates the idea that the free-enterprise system is exceptional. For example, during the Great Depression, the U.S. economy contracted sharply beginning in 1929. The National Bureau of Economic Research identifies the contraction, which began in August 1929 and ended in March 1933, as the worst economic contraction in U.S. history. The money supply fell by over a third.

Meaning that, well into the modern era, and just over 1.5 centuries after independence, the country had experienced economic turmoil. At minimum, the Depression demonstrates that the American market economy was capable of producing economic conditions severe enough to require substantial government intervention. The crisis involved widespread unemployment, bank failures, and significant losses of wealth and property. As a result, the federal government expanded its role in the economy through financial regulation and social programs. The expansion of social welfare programs and government-supported jobs, for example, is especially relevant, as these are semi-socialist economic policies being utilized to solve an economic crisis of the world’s “leading” capitalist nation. This implies that while the free-enterprise system is considered beneficial for the wealth of the nation, the United States may fall on socialist tendencies to repair the health of its economy.

The 2008 financial crisis provides another example of a fault in the United States’ free-enterprise system. The recession associated with the financial crisis began in December 2007 and lasted until June 2009. A notable trend is the dependence the financial system has on substantial government intervention. The Treasury, Federal Reserve, and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation intervened during the 2007-2009 financial crisis. These organizations aimed to increase liquidity, restore capital to financial institutions, purchase illiquid securities, stabilize specific financial markets, and prevent the collapse of major firms labeled as “too big to fail.”

The main goals were to stop financial panic and return to normal market conditions, which were largely achieved. The significance of this intervention is that the American economic system does not operate independently of the government. When private financial institutions became sufficiently unstable to threaten the broader economy, public institutions intervened to stabilize the market itself. These interventions complicate the idea that free enterprise alone can contribute to American economic success. The market was preserved, in part, through government action.

Further analysis indicates that the American market economy has repeatedly experienced severe systemic crises that required government intervention. If the system presented as a defining American strength has repeatedly produced severe instability and required substantial intervention, then its contribution to American exceptionalism is an empirical question, not a fact.

A country’s economic performance can also be evaluated through the opportunities an economic system provides to ordinary citizens. A country cannot easily claim that its economic system is uniquely successful while large portions of its population experience limited opportunities for upward mobility. Despite the economic downturn and stagnant incomes for middle- and lower-class Americans, the belief in the American Dream persists. Writers Janny Scott and David Leonhardt argue that fixed class positions challenge people’s beliefs in equal opportunity and personal success. Their 2010 New York Times poll revealed that 75% of Americans felt that the chance to move up the class ladder had either improved or stayed the same over the past thirty years. Put simply, those who believe in American exceptionalism remain committed to that belief despite economic difficulties.

This discrepancy among Americans creates a tension between belief and experience. Americans may continue to believe in the possibility of upward mobility even when economic conditions make that mobility increasingly difficult. The persistence of belief in the American Dream therefore does not necessarily demonstrate that the promise of equal opportunity is being fulfilled. Instead, it shows how strongly the belief in American exceptionalism can persist even when measurable economic outcomes complicate it.

A person can value the country’s democratic ideals while arguing that its institutions and economic outcomes have failed to consistently fulfill those ideals. In this sense, inequality challenges exceptionalism because it creates a measurable gap between the country’s promises of opportunity and the economic experiences of many of its citizens. In Goniprow’s words, “without serious efforts to reduce income inequality, more will see exceptionalism as a myth rather than a truth.”

Criticism of American exceptionalism does not necessarily mean rejecting the United States itself. The belief that America is exceptional because of its free-enterprise system is empirically testable, and recurring economic failures challenge that belief without proving that alternative economic systems are superior. Additionally, inequality challenges exceptionalism because it creates a measurable gap between the country’s promises of opportunity and the economic experiences of many of its citizens. Therefore, American exceptionalism should be judged by evidence, not assumption. People should define their vision of America rather than assume superiority. In this context, American exceptionalism may simply need refinement.

Categories: Domestic Affairs

Tagged as: , ,

Leave a Reply